Monday, August 23, 2010

Mad Woman?

Hello all,

I hope you are all well as summer begins to wind down. Our summer here in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) has been HOT HOT HOT. I don't remember the last time we had one this hot. No complaints from me, but my electricity bill was a lot higher for this summer than last, and I imagine mine was not the only one.

Anyhoo, on to my post, which I'm sure you're all eager to read! ;)

I've been talking to people lately about the tv show 'Mad Men' and why I don't like it. The people I've been talking to have all been men. They all like the show. In case any of you, my faithful readers, don't know what the show is about:
Set in 1960s New York, the sexy, stylized and provocative AMC drama Mad Men follows the lives of the ruthlessly competitive men and women of Madison Avenue advertising, an ego-driven world where key players make an art of the sell.
That quote is from the AMC (the show's producer) website.

So what's up with me? It's an award-winning show. People seem to love it. It's character driven, it's got snappy dialogue and fabulous wardrobe; and I'm seriously into clothing as those of you who know me know. For years I've been lamenting the fact that people don't know how to dress for work anymore. But I digress.

One of the men I talked to said he thought guys liked the show because it allowed them to revel in a time when men could be men and not have to apologize for their behaviour. My response: Excuse me? Answer: You know, we didn't have to worry about being politically correct and stuff. This conversation can be summed up thusly: He suggested that men enjoyed the show because it was set in a time when men could be as sexist, racist and bigoted as they were naturally inclined to be and didn't have to worry about the repercussions. After a little discussion (read grilling, and I admit that my discussions on topics like this may seem a little like grilling when speaking with someone with this kind of belief) he protested that this was not his opinion, just what he imagined others' opinions are. Right.

Okay, this I get: if you're sexist, racist and/or bigoted, and still wish that white men were as dominant and oppressive as they were fifty years ago, I can completely understand why you would enjoy this show.

Another guy I spoke with told me I was reading too much into it. It's just a show. He doesn't think about it at all and I shouldn't worry about. I shouldn't worry about the rampant misogyny? Nope. It's just a show. Get over it. Move on. This conversation isn't worth having. Okay then. I'll move on.

The last guy I talked to about this show is someone I consider to be not only very liberated but also an entertainment connoisseur. When he asked why I dislike the show I told him I was uncomfortable with how misogynistic it is. During our conversation he pointed out that the show took place during a time when that was the norm and that the show's protagonists were not depicted as heroes, rather they were shown as anti-heroes and that the misogyny was not glamourized but highlighted as something negative. He enjoys the show for the story lines, characters, etc. not for the wistful harkening back to 'better times'. He also pointed out that I sounded a little harsh when talking about it. Okay, maybe I am a little; or maybe a lot. He asked why I was so upset about this particular show when almost anything historical would contain some form of oppression. This is true.

So I've been thinking about this and I've decided I just can't stomach it. Perhaps this show is worst because it's so good; because it's so believable. Perhaps it's because I don't have to suspend any disbelief: I believe in these scenarios; these things could have happened. It's similar to why I don't find slasher movies scary but Silence of the Lambs scared the heck out of me: slasher movies are completely fabricated, but serial killers with anti-social personalities exist.

So I admit it it's me. I don't enjoy watching it. I prefer my entertainment to be fun, or intellectual or something that doesn't make me feel bad. Don't get me wrong: I'm not suggesting that I'm a 'bury my head in the sand and forget about what women have had to go through to get where we are today type of person'. I'm just saying that when I watch t.v. it's because I don't want to think, I just want to enjoy myself and I can't enjoy myself if I'm feeling bad. I'm glad society has changed and I don't really have to deal with treatment like that on a regular basis. Obviously, we're still not equals and sexism still exists. Racism and bigotry of all kinds still exist too, but I think society is moving forward and I am happy that some people are watching what they say and do. Not enough mind you, but at least people are trying and I give them kudos for that.

I look forward to a time when people don't have to worry about political correctness anymore because they won't even be thinking that way. People will have come to the realization that people are people and while different, equal. I'm not naive enough to believe that will happen in my lifetime, but I believe it will happen someday. Maybe then people will watch something like 'Mad Men' and marvel at how pre-historic the people in the twentieth century were.

Until then, be good and drive safe peeps!

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hmmmm. Interestingly enough, we don't get Mad Men, so haven't kept up with it, but there was an episode on tonight and I do get it here in LA. So I watched. I totally get what you are saying, but I agree with your friend. It is supposed to make us squirm - but it does so in an intelligent way - that doesn't simply say "hey, see this guy? he's totally wrong for thinking in this sexist/racist way". It delves into why they thought and acted that way. If it was just wrong and "bad" that wouldn't be an honest betrayal either. The other thing the show does that I do like is show the characters seeing these bad behaviours and questioning them. So in tonight's episode the firm was going after Honda's business. The partner that was a vet from WWII was totally against it and insulted the Japanese owners. The Japanese were blatantly staring at the red head's boobs (sorry, I don't know names...). She had moved on from being a mistress to having a husband about to ship out to war. She told the WWII vet that he wasn't honoring all soldiers with his behavior. Anyway -- lots of complex characterizations going on... The fact that it sparked this blog and the circling debate? That's got to be a good thing, right? That said - I totally understand not wanting to watch tv that just makes you feel bad. I felt the same way about The Shield - lots of critical acclaim, good acting, the type of show I normally love, but I hated all the characters and just didn't enjoy watching...

You did know that my sister is curator of the fashion resource centre at Seneca, didn't you? We should get her to give us the tour at Christmas -- or I can just hook you up with her -- it's an awesome collection....

Phil_Doherty said...

It's a tough debate whether a body of work glamourizes inequity to advance a plot line, or is simply shedding light on it as part of building an atmosphere.

Personally, I found Mad Men boring the one time I tried to watch it.

Unknown said...

I would have to amend my earlier theory, as I feel the third in your research had it closer to right: there is - and should be - a squirmy quality to it. And the historical aspect of the show is painstakingly accurate, but that doesn't mean it's a show for everyone. And I can't imagine you'd be learning anything from Mad Men you don't already know first-hand, Lesley... :P

Anonymous said...

Excellent, excellent blog. I also do not enjoy the show, although I have tried. I really wanted to watch the show, mostly because Jon Hamm is smoking hot and that's what I look for in a show. Does that mean I am like these characters - that the opposite sex is for eye candy and my own selfish needs?

Joke for you (as told by a man) - My girlfriend called me a misogynist. I said 'how does such a pretty little thing like you know such a big word.' - Doogie Horner

Lesley said...

I did NOT know that about your sister and YES we should totally get her to give us a tour if you've got time at Christmas!!!

I do agree about them making us think. I get that, and that's why I used to keep quiet about it. Plus they do dress really well. ; )

Unknown said...

Hey, a little late to the conversation but as someone who loves this show, I find all of the lady-hating, queer-bashing, and racism fascinating.
I don't think we've really progressed all that much. By this I mean, yeah, we all know not to say anything that would be seen as misogynistic, racist or homophobic in mixed company but I think a lot of those attitudes are still very close to the surface.
I find it really interesting how blase and accepting of this stuff people on the show can be. I also love how we're not told a lot but shown things in a way that I don't see too often on TV.
And, I love some of the characters as much as I hate some of the characters. The hate is interesting because if I try to remove the filter of my modern sensibility I can let go of some of the anger I may have towards them and it becomes fascinating again.
Anyway, I love me some Mad Men but I know there are lots of people who think it's overrated or, like yourself, don't enjoy it at all.
It can be a pretty dark ride.
Also: Blog more, please!